Jay Inslee Is A Terrible, But Typical Central Planner

by | Apr 3, 2020 | General | 8 comments

We need a Smarter Stay-At-Home Order.  Gov. Jay Inslee’s current version is causing avoidable collateral damage.

We get it. Flatten the curve, maintain social distance, wash your hands, don’t touch your face and wipe down frequently touched surfaces.

Sure, some people don’t get it and the hunker inside order was necessary. Canceling mass gatherings, getting people out of crowded bars, not requiring people to work in close proximity–an overall throttling back was a good move.

But Jay Inslee has shown that in exercising unprecedented emergency powers he is a very poor central planner.

Let me correct that: he has shown he is just like all other central planners who believe they can run entire economies by deciding what is and is not essential and who should win and lose.

Governor Inslee needs to start getting more of Washington back to work even as he extends his stay-at-home order to May 4. A sick, sputtering economy that devastates businesses and lives for years is looming before us because he has made some quite bad decisions.

In extending his order Governor Insleee did not modify the list of essential businesses, or take any steps toward permitting closed businesses to start resuming or preparing to resume operations. That was a huge mistake. Businesses cannot turn themselves on with the flip of a switch on May 5 and return to the level where they were. They need to start gearing up now.

Anybody who has run a business would know this. Jay Inslee has never run a business, created jobs or steered a business through rocky times.

Take, for instance, construction, one of the most significant sectors of the economy. It has an enormous multiplier effect, positive when doing well, severely negative for everybody in a downturn. And this is not a downturn: it is a suicidal government-mandated nosedive. It’s like Japanese generals chaining pilots to the steering wheels of kamikaze planes. Inslee is the Japanese general; many of the rest of us are chained in our seats on a plane he has ordered to crash.

Governor Inslee could have modified his ban on almost all construction activity by permitting crews limited in size to perform tasks to preserve the job site and work already completed, and prepare for rapid resumption of full activities. Some work can be performed by small teams who need not be in close proximity. Much construction work is done outdoors, where the risk of spreading the virus is much lower than in office settings or Amazon warehouses and pot shops where he is permitting some businesses to continue to operate.

We’ve heard from Inslee that we have a dire housing emergency. But he has shut down all residential construction. Only residential construction funded by government may continue. How does that make sense when the driving rationale is supposed to be stopping the spread of the virus? How is a publicly funded housing project more sterile than one funded by a future homemowner or a bank? Workers do the same tasks, Governor Inslee. But workers on projects he perhaps supports more than others get to continue working.

As projects sit idle, the consequences cascade and multiply. Weather and the turn of seasons are not obeying a huddle-in-place order. “Make hay while the sun shines,” a common sense principle, has been made a criminal violation by Jay Inslee, but not for publicly funded construction work. Or hockey arenas. (You think the Key Arena construction project might have a little more political clout than hopeful homeowners and small contractors?)

Time is money, both in terms of financing and in construction projects’ critical paths, which have now been thrown off course. Skilled labor can be lost if it is not used. Heavy equipment rented for now idled projects can be moved to places where work continues.

Inslee has taken a sledgehammer to construction work. He is imposing maximum damage that use of a scalpel could have avoided.

And it makes no sense.

A person working a piece of heavy equipment is not cheek-to-jowl with another worker. They are alone and isolated in their excavators and cranes and bulldozers. There is no reason for them to be sitting at home while their employer faces bankruptcy.

A man digging a trench is no threat to anyone.

A carpernter on a roof is no threat to anyone.

A plumber crawling under a house is no threat to anyone.

But an economic shutdown that will inflict lasting damage is a threat to everyone.

Look, the Governor is allowing realtors to show properties as long as the house is empty and they are taking only one person at a time. If a couple wants to view the home, one stays outside while the other goes in with the realtor, then they switch. (Realtors and their associations, hmm, who do they support with their vast political contributions?)

Jay Inslee says that buying and selling existing homes, and earning real estate commissions, is an essential activity. But building new homes and apartments is not–unless he’s paying for it.

If Governor Inslee can work out a solution for those buying and selling houses, he can do the same for what is actually a far more critical sector of our economy, one that creates wealth by creating housing from sticks and bricks.

It is easy to take shots at industries and activities the Governor has not shut down, to argue they are not really all that essential, or that they are somehow being favored by the Governor. It is easy because Inslee has made it easy. The point is not to shut them down. If their business can be safely conducted, and they can stay up and running and keep people employed–great, no questions asked.

But I am asking questions about other shutdowns that make no sense, and there are plenty.  Inslee’s errors in judgment are hurting people and will continue to do so for long after he lifts his order.

Jim Scarantino

Jim Scarantino

Jim Scarantino was the editor and founder of Port Townsend Free Press. He is happy in his new role as just a contributor writing on topics of concern to him. He spent the first 25 years of his professional life as a trial attorney, then launched an online investigative news website that broke several national stories. He is also the author of three crime novels. He resides in Jefferson County. See our “About” page for more information.

Comment Guidelines

We welcome contrary viewpoints. Diversity of opinion is sorely lacking in Port Townsend, in part because dissenting views are often suppressed, self-censored and made very unwelcome. Insults, taunts, bullying, all-caps shouting, intimidation, excessive or off-topic posting, and profanity do not qualify as serious discourse, as they deter, dilute, and drown it out. Comments of that nature will be removed and offenders will be blocked. Allegations of unethical, immoral, or criminal behavior need to be accompanied by supporting evidence, links, etc. Please limit comments to 500 words.

8 Comments

  1. Marie

    This is why we need a leader in the White House. We need clear concise direction that is based on scientific evidence not political rhetoric or corporate greed. Yes, we all can say how good or badly someone is doing, but there is no guidelines that have been enacted to cope with this crisis. https://www.commondreams.org/views/2018/05/21/coming-collapse?utm_campaign=shareaholic&utm_medium=referral&utm_source=facebook&fbclid=IwAR381ElBPrzrmJh7J95Ro2qElCEhwlrtYn1musJ0k83JBJxDtGSWLbIhYeM I suggest everyone read this well written piece by Chris Hedges.

    Reply
    • Ole S. Birkland

      The White House has nothing to do with states closing down local industries, stores or businesses. The president has rightly left this issue to the states, each of which can use their own circumstances and discretion to manage affairs as they see fit.

      But leave it to the Port Townsend leftists to use any and every opportunity to disparage this president, who has for the most part done well confronting a totally unexpected health crisis. His greatest impediments so far have been, (1) a totally corrupt World Health Organization that panders to, and lies for, the Chinese Communist government, and (2) the inept, Deep State impaired, Center For Disease Control, whose doctors have totally missed the mark on their predictions regarding the spread of the disease. The CDC officials had also failed to restock supplies (surgical masks, etc) depleted by the H1N1 flu epidemic of 2009-10. But then, perhaps nine years is insufficient for this to take place.

      Reply
      • Hilda

        This is not and should not be a political issue! Agree- Inslee needs to rethink like a businessman rather than a politician. Strong economy keeps this country as we know it – the long term economic effects of Inslee’s ban will be more devastating than most people realize

        Reply
        • Ole S. Birkland

          I totally agree with your opinion that the governor’s current stay at home policy will devastate businesses, and especially small businesses. Yesterday, while returning from a food run to Ferinos Pizza, I noted three small restaurants in the Port Hadlock had closed. Will they ever reopen?

          My opinion is to restrict the ‘stay at home’ policy to seniors (65+) and those with health issues. Restrict public gatherings (restaurants and bars, etc), but allow manufacturing, construction and service industries to continue operating, if workers can maintain safe spacing.

          Note: I only mentioned politics to refute Marie’s disparaging remarks regarding the President, who was not even mentioned in Jim Scarantino’s article.

          Reply
  2. Rita Hubbard

    His biggest problem – he won’t take advice from anyone – he is a know-it-all and very narcissistic. All your points are correct – get our people back to work!

    Reply
    • Ole S. Birkland

      I agree also with the author’s article, that Jay Inslee is a know-it-all, very narcissistic and won’t take advice from anyone. He wasted much time and many dollars from our state treasury in a futile run for president, knowing he hadn’t a prayer. As it turned out, less than 1% of Democrats found his campaign, centered on man-made “Climate Change” nonsense, worthy of their support.

      Reply
  3. John Saley

    Have you ever worked construction? By reading this my guess is no. I’m in the construction trades and have very seldom been on a job site where I’ve been able to avoid close proximity to anyone.

    Reply
    • Jim Scarantino

      I have worked construction. Built houses, painted houses, dug trenches for footings, did roofing and laid down asphalt, as well as remodeling homes. All of those things can be done without being on top of someone else. Plus I just spoke with a small contractor who had been working on a 3500 sf house. Just him and one other man and he says they could have managed social distancing, but instead he is now unemployed and losing money. Have also heard from a plumber who works alone that he is out of work, and an electrician, also, in the same situation.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.